Skip to main content
Articles / XTB vs NAGA: 2023 Comparison

XTB vs NAGA: 2023 Comparison

Franklin Carneiro da Silva| Updated: February 27, 2023

Are you confused about whether to choose XTB vs NAGA as a broker for your investing needs?

In this side-by-side comparison, we analyse XTB vs NAGA to help you understand how these apps compare on some of the most common features and make a better-informed decision about the best broker for you.

Below, you’ll find the pros and cons of each broker, as well as a comparison table that features the different fees charged, the financial instruments supported, the regulation, and more. Keep reading!

XTB vs NAGA: 2023 Comparison 1
Visit XTBAsset 3

79% of retail CFD account lose money.

Ideal for
Commission-free ETFs and CFDs trading

XTB is a well-known online broker listed on the Warsaw Stock Exchange. It has two trading platforms (xStation 5 and xStation Mobile), a diverse range of tradeable instruments, and exceptional customer service.

xStation Mobile is a premier application for charts and technical analysis, with the ability to apply numerous indicators like moving averages and volume. Navigation is simple, with an intuitive order placing for any asset class.

On the negative side, XTB has a limited product portfolio and charges a €10 monthly inactivity fee (after 1+ year with no activity plus no deposit in the last 90 days).

XTB vs NAGA: 2023 Comparison 2
Visit NAGAAsset 3

87.36% of retail CFD accounts lose money.

Ideal for
Social trading only

NAGA is a German fintech created to give you easy access to the investment world. Their motto is simple: “financial inclusion for everyone”.

It offers social trading, a multi-currency account, a demo account, and several ways to deposit and withdraw your money.

On the downside, their ETF offering is not clear (real ETFs are mixed with CFDs on ETFs), and it doesn’t offer commission-free real stock trading.

Pros and Cons

Pros

  • Free stocks trading (only applicable to some EU countries)
  • Customizable trading platform (charts and workspace)
  • Low Forex Spreads
  • Demo account
  • No minimum account deposit
  • Valuable education materials
  • Top-tier Regulators

Cons

  • Complex trading platform for a beginner
  • High Stock CFD fees
  • Limited product portfolio
  • Withdrawal fees for transfers below $100
  • Inactivity fee (€10/monthly after 1+ year with no activity plus no deposit in the last 90 days)

Pros

  • Social trading feature (Automatically copy or follow other people’s trade)
  • Wide range of financial products
  • Multi-currency accounts: USD, EUR, GBP, PLN, UST, and NGC (NAGA coin)
  • No currency conversion fee
  • Modern and user-friendly Web and Mobile interfaces
  • NAGA Mastercard
  • NAGA Group AG is publicly listed company (ISIN: DE000A161NR7)
  • Demo account

Cons

  • No commission-free stock trading
  • The “top-performing traders” may be disguised as “temporarily lucky”
  • Offers primarily CFDs, which are high-risk instruments with no asset ownership
  • Up to $5 in withdrawal fees
  • No clear distinction between real ETFs and CFD ETFs
  • Poor distinction between “NAGA Markets Europe Ltd” And “NAGA Global Ltd”
XTB vs NAGA: 2023 Comparison 3
XTB vs NAGA: 2023 Comparison 4
  •  
  • General Information
  • Founded in
  • Demo Account
  • Account Minimum
  • Interest on unninvested cash (annually)
  • Products
  • Stocks
  • ETFs
  • Bonds
  • Funds
  • Options
  • Futures
  • CFDs
  • Leverage Products
  • Forex
  • Cryptocurrencies
  • Commodities
  • Fees
  • US stocks
  • EU stocks
  • ETFs
  • Cryptocurrencies
  • Custody Fee
  • Inactivity Fee
  • Withdrawal Fee
  • Connectivity Fee
  • Currency Conversion Fee
  • Security
  • Regulators
  • Investor Compensation Scheme(per person, per institution)
  • XTBAsset 3

    79% of retail CFD account lose money.

  • General Information
  • Founded in2002
  • Demo Account
  • Account Minimum€/$/£1
  • Interest on unninvested cash (annually)0%
  • Products
  • Stocks*Only in some countries.
  • ETFs*Only in some countries.
  • Bonds
  • Funds
  • Options
  • Futures
  • CFDs*On Stocks, ETFs, Forex, Indices, and Commodities.
  • Leverage Products
  • Forex
  • Cryptocurrencies
  • Commodities
  • Fees
  • US stocks€0**Up to €100.000 in monthly volume transactions - Only applicable in some countries.
  • EU stocks€0**Up to €100.000 in monthly volume transactions - Only applicable in some countries.
  • ETFs€0**Up to €100.000 in monthly volume transactions - Only applicable in some countries.
  • CryptocurrenciesNot Applicable**Spreads from 0.22% on Crypto CFDs.
  • Custody Fee€0
  • Inactivity Fee€10/month**After 1 year login inactivity and if no deposit was made in the previous 90 days.
  • Withdrawal Fee€0
  • Connectivity Fee€0
  • Currency Conversion Fee0.50%
  • Security
  • RegulatorsFCA and CySEC.
  • Investor Compensation Scheme(per person, per institution)

    Up to €20,000 for clients under XTB SA; Up to £85,000 for clients under XTB Limited.

  • NAGAAsset 3

    87.36% of retail CFD accounts lose money.

  • General Information
  • Founded in2015
  • Demo Account
  • Account Minimum$250
  • Interest on unninvested cash (annually)0%
  • Products
  • Stocks*Only in Naga Europe.
  • ETFs*Only in Naga Europe.
  • Bonds
  • Funds
  • Options
  • Futures
  • CFDs*On Stocks, Indices, Cryptocurrencies, Commodities, and Futures.
  • Leverage Products
  • Forex
  • Cryptocurrencies
  • Commodities
  • Fees
  • US stocks0.10% of the total traded amount**Min. $6 (only in NAGA Europe).
  • EU stocks0.10% of the total traded amount**Min. €8 (only in NAGA Europe).
  • ETFs0.10% of the total traded amount.
  • CryptocurrenciesNot Applicable**It charges a variable spread on crypto CFDs.
  • Custody Fee€0
  • Inactivity Fee€0
  • Withdrawal Fee$5**On bank transfers ($10 with other methods).
  • Connectivity Fee€0
  • Currency Conversion Fee0%
  • Security
  • RegulatorsCySEC
  • Investor Compensation Scheme(per person, per institution)

    Up to €20,000.

Franklin Carneiro da Silva
Co-Founder & Fintech Analyst

Franklin is a CFA Level III Candidate with 3 years of experience in Wealth Management as a Fund Research Analyst and the Host of the "Edge Over Hedge" YouTube Channel.

linkedin
youtube